Get My Home Value

Home Values · Suffolk County · Shelter Island, NY

What's your home worth in Shelter Island?

The median home in Shelter Island sold for $2,250,000 — single-family prices ▲ 50% over the past year.

FreeNo obligationSell for 1.99%, not 6%
$2,250,000
Median sale price
16
Homes sold (12 mo)
▲ 50%
1-year single-family trend
Single-family$2,250,000· 16 sold

Based on recorded residential sales over the last 12 months (all home types). Source: ATTOM public property records · updated quarterly · as of July 2026.

About the neighborhood

An island on its own clock

You arrive by ferry or not at all. Set between Long Island's North and South Forks, Shelter Island runs on a slower clock, its name an echo of an older one, Manhansack-aha-quash-awamock, island sheltered by islands. Nearly a third of the land is preserved, most notably in the Mashomack Nature Preserve, where trails cross oak woodland, tidal creeks, and salt marsh; Crescent and Silver Beach offer quiet sand, and protected bays favor sailing and kayaking.

The built landscape stays historic: Stick-Eastlake, Queen Anne, and Colonial Revival houses in the Heights, colonial-era homes on leafy lanes, weathered barns and stone walls, and Sylvester Manor carrying the island's layered past. A small school, the library, farmers markets, and a handful of local businesses cover town life, which is exactly the scale most residents want.

Shelter Island, Suffolk County

Where Shelter Island sits

The official neighborhood boundary — every sale behind the numbers above closed inside this outline.

Shelter Island · Suffolk County

The locqube difference

Selling in Shelter Island? Keep more of your equity.

On a $2,250,000 sale, a traditional 6% commission is about $135,000. With locqube it's a flat $899 or 1.99% — keeping more of what you built.

Traditional 6%
$135,000
locqube · 1.99%
$44,775
or flat fee
$899
~$90,225
more kept in your pocket
1.99% fee Dedicated in-house agent AI valuation

Possible because our agents are in-house and one platform does the busywork — savings we pass to you. Run your own numbers →

"
They made it so easy — we felt cared for, heard and appreciated.
NS
Nick & Katie Simpson
Saved $25,877 in commissions

Find out what your Shelter Island home is worth.

Nearby neighborhoods

Questions, answered

The fastest way to find out is a free locqube valuation. Enter your address and we'll combine recent Shelter Island sales, your home's size and condition, and live market data into an accurate, no-obligation estimate — usually in under a minute.
The median home in Shelter Island sold for about $2,250,000 across 16 recorded sales in the past year — all home types combined. Among single-family homes, the area's most-sold type, prices moved ▲ 50% year over year. Your home's value depends on its size, condition and exact location.
From recorded residential sales in Shelter Island over the trailing 12 months — all home types, sourced from ATTOM public property records and refreshed quarterly. It reflects what actually closed, not asking prices.
Yes — New York and Connecticut owners can sell by owner, and locqube's Self-Serve plan backs you with MLS exposure, locqube AI guiding every step, and a live dashboard for a flat $899. A licensed agent stays one tap away whenever you want one. How selling by owner works → The New York by-owner guide →
List with locqube — a flat $899 or 1.99% instead of the traditional 6%, with a dedicated in-house agent and AI-powered pricing. On a typical Shelter Island sale that keeps roughly $90,225 more in your pocket.

Ready when you are

See your Shelter Island home's value.