The buyer is asking for money after closing — do I have to pay?
Short answer: not automatically. A properly disclosed, as-is sale protects you from most after-the-fact money requests. It does not protect you if you knew about a real problem and hid it. Everything depends on what was actually disclosed and what's actually being alleged.
What "as-is" actually protects you from
An as-is sale, backed by an honest property condition disclosure, is built to close the door on buyer's remorse: normal wear, things a home inspector should have caught, or a buyer who simply wishes they'd negotiated harder. If you disclosed what you knew and the buyer had a full inspection period, "the water heater is older than I realized" is not a claim that survives closing.
What it does not protect you from
As-is has never shielded a seller who knew about a serious defect and actively concealed it — painted over a active leak, papered over mold, disconnected a sensor before an inspection. Courts treat that as fraud or intentional concealment, and an as-is clause does not cover it. The dividing line is simple to state and important to sit with: did you know, and did you hide it? If the honest answer is no to both, you're on solid ground.
The legal clock
In New York, claims for breach of contract or fraud generally have to be brought within six years of the sale, or within two years of when the buyer discovered — or reasonably should have discovered — the problem, whichever gives more time. That's a long window, but it also means an old, expired claim is genuinely dead, not just quiet. Connecticut's timelines run differently and depend on the specific claim — your closing attorney can tell you exactly where you stand if something comes up.
What an escrow holdback actually is (and isn't)
An escrow holdback is a small amount of your proceeds set aside at closing for a known, already-agreed issue — a repair that couldn't be finished in time, a permit still pending. It's arranged and documented before closing, with both sides' attorneys involved and clear conditions for releasing the funds. It is not something a buyer can invoke after the fact for a new complaint — if nothing was set aside at closing, a surprise call three months later demanding money is not an escrow holdback, it's a new claim, and it needs to be treated as one.
What to actually do if you get that call or letter
Don't ignore it, and don't negotiate it yourself over the phone. Send it straight to the attorney who handled your closing — they have the disclosure, the inspection record, and the contract in front of them, and they'll tell you quickly whether this is a real exposure or a request that has no legal footing. Most of these resolve fast once an attorney is in the loop; what turns a nuisance ask into a real problem is a seller who engages directly and says something they don't mean to.
Questions sellers ask
Does an as-is sale mean I don't have to disclose anything?
No. In New York, you're still legally required to disclose material known defects (or pay a credit in lieu of the disclosure form). "As-is" describes who fixes what going forward — it doesn't excuse you from telling the truth about what you know today.
What counts as a "material" defect I'd need to disclose?
Anything that would reasonably affect a buyer's decision or the price they'd pay — active leaks, structural issues, known mold, failed systems. When in doubt, disclose; the honest paper trail is what protects you later.
Should I get my own inspection before listing?
It's not required, but a pre-listing inspection lets you disclose accurately, price honestly, and walk into a buyer's inspection with no surprises on either side — which is exactly what keeps a sale from turning into a post-closing dispute.
Selling with a clean, honest paper trail matters more than most sellers realize. See your home's real value, backed by recorded sales, not guesswork.
By Manuel Pantiga, licensed real estate broker (New York & Connecticut) and co-founder of locqube. This is general information, not legal advice — talk to your closing attorney about your specific situation.
Wondering about your own house?
Free value estimate for any NY or CT address. In seconds, no agent visit.
See what my house is worth →Or start your listing — $899 flat, or a dedicated agent at 1.99%.
See the whole decision with real numbers in it.
Your home's value from recorded sales around it, your equity, and what the sale actually costs — before you talk to anyone.
Get my free home estimate